MP makes access to Carf more difficult for micro, small and medium-sized companies
In observe, solely administrative processes that exceed the worth of 1 thousand minimal wages, equal at present to greater than R$ 1.3 million, could be judged by CARF. Underneath the rule that was in impact previous to the provisional measure, taxpayers with disputes involving not less than BRL 78,120.00 could be entitled to enchantment to CARF.
Federal deputy Joaquim Passarinho (PL-PA) claims that the change will hurt taxpayers whose tax disputes with the Union will not be so excessive.
“Most Brazilian firms do not even have revenues of R$ 1.3 million. Think about a effective. So, you’ll depart Carf restricted to massive firms. That’s, small and medium-sized firms in Brazil is not going to have the possibility of an administrative enchantment. You might be stopping small and medium-sized firms from with the ability to query their debt or effective in an administrative method and never in a judicial method”, he criticizes.
In response to the vice-president of the Brazilian Institute of Planning and Taxation (IBPT), Letícia Amaral, tax disputes between firms or people and the Union are beginning to be judged, within the first occasion, at one of many Federal Income Judgment Workplaces (DRJ ). The CARF, due to this fact, works as a second and final occasion in order that taxpayers who really feel aggrieved can nonetheless enchantment on the administrative stage, that’s, with out involving the Judiciary.
She explains that, in 2020, when the Nationwide Congress ended the casting vote, parliamentarians set the minimal worth of 60 minimal wages in order that tax disputes could possibly be analyzed by Carf. “They restricted entry to the Carf, however maintained a twin jurisdiction inside the trial station. in monetary phrases”, he explains.
The federal government’s MP made entry to the council much more restricted. Consequently, all tax administrative proceedings of as much as roughly R$ 1.3 million will likely be thought of solely on the DRJ, not having the opportunity of going to the CARF.
In response to Passarinho, to proceed defending themselves, the small taxpayer must take the dispute to the Judiciary, which tends to extend prices for firms and residents, along with the length of the tax course of. Micro, small and medium-sized firms, in response to the parliamentarian, are at a loss.
“This can deliver a good higher demand to the Judiciary, which doesn’t have a tax specialization to hold out this monitoring and judgment of a tax debt, as a result of it is extremely particular. equity in case you are taking out greater than 80% of the businesses that may search for Carf”, he evaluates.
Quality vote makes Carf partial, says IBPT vice-president
Return of the casting vote is an offense to the constitutional process, according to tax expert
Agreement between Ministry of Finance and OAB on Carf does not favor taxpayers
MP 1160/2023
Since 2020, Regulation 13.988/20 established that ties must be determined in favor of the taxpayer. The challenge was justified by the seek for extra neutral choices within the judgment of tax proceedings on the administrative stage.
With the reintegration of the casting vote, the advisors representing the Nationwide Treasury, who’re the presidents of teams and chambers in Carf, will be capable to tie the votes in favor of the Union.
The resumption of the casting vote initially got here within the type of provisional measure 1160/2023, introduced by the federal government in January of this yr, as a part of the fiscal package deal that goals to enhance public accounts.
The MP has the pressure of legislation and is already legitimate for the processes which might be judged within the Carf. The Nationwide Congress has 60 days to research it. The deadline is extendable for one more 60 days, if the Chamber and the Senate haven’t voted on the measure.
By Brasil 61
